The 12 Best Airbnbs In Fire Island, New York

November 15, 2020
Airbnb
" class="img-responsive wp-image-731235 wp-post-image" alt="" />
At Yore Oyster, we strive to help you make wise financial decisions. We're committed to giving you the most relevant, actionable advice anywhere.

If you’re looking for the best Airbnbs in Fire Island, you’ve come to the right place. We combed through thousands of Airbnb listings in Fire Island and the surrounding area to find the homes with the best amenities and the most positive reviews at the lowest prices.

#1 Studio In Prominent 1960’s Beachhouse

2 Guests | 1 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $300 per night, airbnb.com

This stunning three-bedroom studio stands out thanks to its impressive architecture of minimalism and modernism. This home also comes with a viewing deck overlooking the Great South Bay plus large and spacious interiors. City dwellers looking to have a staycation away from tiny NYC apartments will find this listing a breath of fresh air.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Studio with private entrance in stunning 3 br. , the Frank House & Geller’s finest work, this design set the pace for Fire Island pines to become a focal point of modernism in the 60s & 70s. “

Amenities

Heating | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer | Hot water | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Essentials | Wifi | Pool | Kitchen | Refrigerator

#2 Oceanview Hideaway

6 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $250 per night, airbnb.com

Surfing, kayaking, paddleboarding, and biking are all the kinds of outdoor activities you can do when you book yourself at this two-bedroom cottage overlooking Ocean Beach. It’s the perfect place for an NYC summer getaway and perfect for hosting you and five other guests. You’ll go to sleep lulled by the ocean waves and wake up to the soft rays of the rising sun.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“New Listing in the Exclusive Corneille Estates located in Ocean Beach, Fire IslandSoak in the sun and ocean views in this Fire Island 2 bedroom peaceful retreat! Great for families, groups of friends or couples with kids. ★ Hurry and reserve your 2019 beach getaway before your dates are booked! ★ Linens and towels provided!”

Amenities

Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Essentials | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer | Hot water | Wifi | Refrigerator | Dishes and silverware | Cooking basics | Coffee maker

Guest Reviews

“Very relaxing holiday with the family! Great place, great location. Darren and Tommy were very helpful and responsive in their communication.” – Karthik
“Great and clean place in a quiet area of ocean beach but a quick walk from the town and the ferry! The ocean views were great! Would stay again!” – Marc
“Tommy was a great host! We had a wonderful stay. We can’t wait to go back!” – Shuji
“Great location! Perfect for us and our two kiddos.” – Samantha
“A great place with a great view.” – Glenn

#3 Beach House In Kismet, Fire Island

10 Guests | 4 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $390 per night, airbnb.com

Cure yourself of stress with some relaxing beach time at this vintage beach house, with a private dock where you can catch a blood orange sunset with cocktails before heading back to the house or restaurants for dinner. With four bedrooms, this beach house can host 10 guests, making it a great spot for a girl’s trip or a guy’s trip.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“60’s modern/retro, award-winning (design) house. 45 secs to beach. Spacious, clean, social- well suited for groups and families (up to 10 max please, 8 is ideal). Fabulous retro mid house, open-roofed porch.”

Amenities

Heating | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer | Indoor fireplace | Washer | Oven | Kitchen | Refrigerator | Dishes and silverware | Cooking basics | Microwave

Guest Reviews

“If you’re about the high vibes/low maintenance lifestyle, Motel O is the place for you! Thanks, Wally!” – Ranna
“Fun times at classic beach house.” – Dan
“Cool spot, as described” – Luke
“Just ended an awesome girls weekend at Motel O. The house is exactly as described and it‘ s location is perfect. A 2 minute walk to the beach was even better.” – Christine
“Wally was awesome and answered all our questions in a timely matter. We had great time at Motel-o!!” – Brooke

#4 Stunning Luxury On Ocean Beach With Private Pool

10 Guests | 4 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $960 per night, airbnb.com

Located on the beach side of Ocean Beach and steps from the sand, this stunning newly constructed home is cloaked in luxury. Every morning greets you to the beautiful sound of birds singing, the beautiful landscape to take a walk or a jog, plus a BBQ grill for a great, smokey grilled dinner. This house can host up to 10 people, making it an ideal getaway for friends or family.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“A refreshing private pool offers guests multiple options to sunbathe on a hot summer day. 109 Bungalow offers great spaces to relax, entertain, dine, unwind and enjoy each day at your own pace. Everything you and your guests will need to enjoy your vacation is provided from bicycles, to beach chairs, beach umbrellas, BBQ, beach toys, pool floats and more.”

Amenities

Iron | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Essentials | Heating | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer | Hot water | Wifi | Indoor fireplace | Children’s books and toys | Pool

Guest Reviews

“I’ve been going to fire island for 15 years. This is by far the nicest place I’ve stayed in. Clean and pristine, beautiful views!” – Benajmin
“The 109 Bungalow was the perfect escape from the city we needed. Evan was a great host and accommodated our arrival. The house was sparkling clean, many accommodations such as sunblock, bug spray, bicycles etc.” – Radena
“Our stay at the Bungalow was everything we expected. Evan made the process smooth and easy. The house is in great proximity of the beach and the town.” – Nick

#5 Amazing Fully Furnished Home Near Fire Island Ferries

4 Guests | 1 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $150 per night, airbnb.com

Beautiful home with wood-panelled walls, hanging plants, and retro furniture welcomes a family or group of 4 looking for a centrally located listing within all major roadways on Fire Island. If you are in town for business or even for a mid-to-long-term stay, this home is ideal with all the amenities and furnishings you will need to make it comfortable and relaxing.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“*Alternative to High Priced Fire Island yet minutes away! *Amazing Fully Furnished Ground level apartment with Office, Private Front Entrance and Private Deck *Daily, Weekly, Monthly. Seasonal rates “Hotel Style Setting- Turn-key Apartment !”

Amenities

Iron | Laptop-friendly workspace | Essentials | Beach essentials | Heating | Cable TV | Air conditioning | TV | Hot water | Wifi | Free street parking | Single level home

Guest Reviews

“Beautifully decorated place. Good proximity. I could not have asked for a better place to spend a few days near Fire Island or a better host.” – Kefah
“Angel’s place was really nice and exactly as advertised. We had a very comfortable and fun stay. He is super friendly and responsive.” – Vandana
“Angel is such a great host! Place was clean, comfortable and conveniently located. We will definitely book again in the future.” – Dennys
“Angel was such a wonderful host. He got to us some food and always willing to help with the staying.” – Fernanda
“Very unique and stylish house, with excellent amenities, and places to go to nearby.” – Abel

#6 Brand New Home With Game Room

12 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $300 per night, airbnb.com

This home is outfitted with plenty of entertainment details to ensure all 12 guests will have an enjoyable, fun-filled holiday weekend. A ping pong table, a poker table plus a fire pit ensures you have something to do all day and all night long. It’s also a short distance to Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge, Cupsogue Beach County Park and Splish Splash Water Park.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Beautiful brand new home, near the beach and the Hamptons! We have board games, a ping pong table, a poker table and a tv with Netflix! Hangout by the firepit on chilly nights or stay in the Central A/C on those hot days. Play outside with the kids or watch them play from the hammock.”

Amenities

Iron | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Essentials | Heating | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer | Hot water | Indoor fireplace | Wifi | Bathtub

Guest Reviews

“Lovely home, beautifully equipped. Perfect to get away to the fork” – Christopher
“Good value and convenient to get to the beach, there’s also a grocery store close by. The design of the space is nice and the neighborhood is quiet at night ” – Emily
“Very enjoyable stay! We had a wonderful girls trip, great location, big backyard! Supermarket is only 5 mins away.” – Penny
“It is a great place to go with friends! the location was great. It was a good bargain!” – Reed
“We had a great time at Felix’s place- the game room and fire pit made the place extra special. We did two day trips to the beach and bbq’s at night- great value and find.” – Adriana
Let’s Cut The Crap

The Best Airbnbs In 5 Minutes Or Less

Stop wasting time searching for the best Airbnbs. Our “10 Or Less” strategy will show you the unique search method we use to find the top Airbnbs in any city in under 5 minutes—guaranteed. Sign up for instant access.

#7 Cozy Fire Island Studio With Deck, Walk to the Beach

2 Guests | 0 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $190 per night, airbnb.com

Just nice for a couple looking for a fuss-free stay in Fire Island. Turn on the flat-screen satellite TV and make yourself a drink to toast to a great weekend. Grab a seat at the breakfast bar and chow down a sandwich from the toaster before you hit the beach. Spend the rest afternoon on the spacious decks and as night falls, rest your head on the comfy full bed for a quiet night’s sleep. Wake up feeling refreshed and ready for another memorable day on Fire Island.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Take a memorable trip to Fire Island and stay at this quaint 1-bathroom studio condo! Situated in the Seashore Condo Motel, this unit provides up to 2 guests with all of the comforts of home for a relaxing and carefree beach vacation. You’ll be close to everything the island has to offer and walking distance from the beach. When you’re not out and about, spend your days sunning on the deck, barbecuing, and spending time with that special someone.”

Amenities

Bed linens | Refrigerator | Ethernet Connection| Bathroom Essentials | Microwave | Heating | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer |Waterfont | BBQ Grill | Pool

Guest Reviews

“Jeff and Brett were really nice to us. They are open-minded, communicate clearly and make sure you’re comfortable. They offered us a heater which we thought was very considerate.” – Elie
“The seashore condo hotel exceeded my expectations. Jeff and Brett are delightful hosts, every detail is thought through. There’s a well maintained outdoor shower, which was a pleasant surprise!” – Emily
“Great space, clean and nice location, friendly hosts, would definitely come back!” – Joseph
“Jeff is a great host and the place is awesome- nice and clean, right amenities! ” – Pepe
“Exceeded my expectations! The location is perfect, so close to the ferry, beach, restaurants. The amenities are great with the deck, grill, bikes.” – Anne

#8 Classic Yacht Near Fire Island Pines

4 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $350 per night, airbnb.com

Fun, adventure and privacy are guaranteed at this beautiful, classic yacht off the coast of Fire Island Pines. It’s definitely a cool and unique stay on a beautiful vintage boat, with 3 comfortable and adequately spacious bedrooms. It’s the perfect listing to enjoy a beautiful summer on Fire Island.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“We would love to share our beautiful yacht with you at the Pines. The sunrise and sunset views are breathtaking at our location. We are close to town yet in a private location. It is the perfect location for the Pines Party weekend!”

Amenities

Air conditioning | Hot water | Essentials | Kitchen | Refrigerator | Stove | Dishes and silverware | Microwave | Coffee maker | Private entrance | Hair dryer | Hangers

Guest Reviews

“Lawrence was an incredible host and super attentive before, during, and after the trip. The yacht was perfect to see all the action in the harbor and was the just the right size for us on a short trip.” – Ryan
“Lawrence was amazing and accommodating- he even shared a welcome drink with us. He is very proud of his boat. He was very available to me at all times.” – Jose
“A unique experience on a really different island, lots of relaxation and fun!” – Aida
“What an amazing experience on Lawrence’s yacht! It is beautifully decorated and totally comfortable. We easily accommodated three people and made use of the kitchen. Everything was perfect”- Ale
“Very cool and unique stay on a beautiful vintage boat. Comfortably accommodated my group of 6. Lawrence is an awesome host!” – Jenny

#9 Pines Home With Pool & Spa

8 Guests | 4 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $900 per night, airbnb.com

A unique Horace Gifford home, this architecturally beautiful home has four bedrooms and is nestled in a quiet pathway towards the beach. It’s the perfect place for a good escape from the city, being together with friends in the sun and the beach. There is a great backyard pool, hot tub and deck space plus the unique arches in the living room and outdoor showers give the home its extra charm.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Bright home with secluded pool and hot tub and outdoor shower. Pool & spa cleaned on Mondays and Thursdays (both have chlorine). Air conditioners in two bedrooms. This home is a nestled is on the far side of the Pines, short walk to the beach. You will have full access to the house.”

Amenities

Beach essentials | Washer | Essentials | Heating | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer | Hot water | Wifi | Hot tub | Single level home | Pool

Guest Reviews

“The owner was very responsive and incredibly proactive about tending to our various needs. It was a great experience.” – Janet
“Good location, nice sized pool.” – Sam
“The architecture of the house is beautiful. Beautiful pool, and the hot tub was lovely at night. A good escape from the city.” – Paul
“We spent the full month of June and wish we could have stayed longer. It was just the break we needed from the city . The house is on a quiet walk with a great backyard pool, hot tub and deck space.” – Fred

#10 Cali House In Ocean Beach

14 Guests | 5 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $330 per night, airbnb.com

Looking for an Airbnb listing to host 14 friends in NY? This listing is the perfect solution. It’s ideally located close to many popular sites on Fire Island such as Fire Island National Seashore, Cherry Grove, and Robert Moses State Park. There are 5 bedrooms but 12 beds in total plus plenty of space to relax, entertain and make memories with friends and family.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Great for friends or a family. House includes 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms , kitchen, large wrap around deck with new outdoor furniture and new BBQ, outdoor shower, large living room, wall unit air conditioners in each room.”

Amenities

Iron | Washer | Essentials | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer | Hot water | Wifi | Refrigerator | Dishes and silverware | Cooking basics | Coffee maker

Guest Reviews

“Roberts place is exactly as advertised. Perfect location. We didn’t know what to expect of Fire Island and Robert really helped with planning and answering all of my questions.” – Brittany
“An amazing host with good insight and attention to detail. Location was perfect and the house is such great value for money.” – Noreen

#11 Smith Point: Pool & Hot Tub Escape

8 Guests | 4 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms

Book Now: $300 per night, airbnb.com

One and a half hours away from New York City sits this 4-bedroom luxury home with an in-ground swimming pool and hot tub. The cleverly planned lighting all around the house adds a touch of warmth and exclusiveness. The covered deck overlooking the pool is a unique place to dine al fresco rain or shine. This listing is perfect for 8 friends celebrating a bachelor or bachelorette party close to NYC.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Escape to Smith Point! Spend the day at the nearby beach or lounge around the in-ground pool & hot tub. Central A/C will keep you cool & comfortable on humid summer days while the warm glow from the fireplace & fire pit chase away chills on cold nights.”

Amenities

Iron | Laptop-friendly workspace | Essentials | Heating | Cable TV | Air conditioning | TV | Indoor fireplace | Hot water | Wifi | Pool | Hot tub

Guest Reviews

“The house is beautiful and comfortable. Super clean. Communication with the host was great.” – George
“We did a family staycation here and it was absolutely perfect. Loved the pool and the hot tub.” – Darian
“Everything about this house exceeds expectations-the decor, location and amenities! We had an amazing weekend here with our pup.” – Mei
“Back yard, pool and deck were all very spacious and we thoroughly enjoyed! Carlo was very responsive to all our questions and concerns which was appreciated. ” – Barbara
“Wonderful stay here. Very comfortable and spacious for two of us. Great amenities too”- James

#12 Two-Bedroom Modern Apartment

4 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $400 per night, airbnb.com

Call this place home for a couple of days to relax, and chill with four other people. You’ll find that the private outdoor roof deck with the large hammock will become your favorite place as it is the piece-de-resistance of this home. The entire place is furnished with simplicity and style plus it’s a short walk to Cherry Grove and the Sunken Forest.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Classic updated 50’s modern design, 2 bedroom apt w/private 700sq roof deck w/10 seater dining table. Spacious Kitchen, comfortable living room, gas grill. Large front deck opening up from the living room for al fresco dining. New this year ** outdoor shower** Shared Washer & dryer.”

Amenities

Washer | Essentials | Cable TV | Air conditioning | TV | Dryer | Hot water | Wifi | Refrigerator | Dishes and silverware | Dishwasher | Cooking basics

Guest Reviews

“What a wonderfully relaxing stay in a beautifully stylish home. The pictures don’t do it justice.” – Lance
“This is the perfect island get away home! Beautiful upper deck to sit and read and enjoy the views. We would love to come back every year!” – Shae
“Great indoor and outdoor space. So close to the beach and the dock. Favorite space was the private outdoor roof deck with the large hammock.” – Derrick
“Just as described – and so close to the beach…perfect location and just right for a lovely stay on the beach!” – Richard
“Super clean with beautiful outdoor spaces, and very close to the beach. Quiet and peaceful. We loved staying here!” – Will
Straight To Your Inbox

Airbnbs Of The Week

A weekly digest of the most spectacular new Airbnbs around the world - all for $150/night or less. Every Friday.