The 12 Best Airbnbs in Indianapolis, Indiana

December 3, 2020
Airbnb
" class="img-responsive wp-image-731235 wp-post-image" alt="" />
At Yore Oyster, we strive to help you make wise financial decisions. We're committed to giving you the most relevant, actionable advice anywhere.

If you’re looking for the best Airbnbs in Indianapolis, you’ve come to the right place. We combed through thousands of Airbnb listings in Indianapolis and the surrounding area to find the homes with the best amenities and the most positive reviews at the lowest prices.

#1 Radiant Townhouse in Broad Ripple

4 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $140 per night, airbnb.com

Colourful, modern and chic are just some of the qualities of the decor in this lovely townhouse. With bright, beautiful spaces as well as a full kitchen and WiFi, this will make your stay in Indianapolis feel like you were staying at a home away from home.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“This bright home adorned with contemporary furnishings and stylish artworks is conveniently located nearby cafes, restaurants and markets. Relax in the comfort of this updated interior or hit the Monon Trail for a morning run! The newly renovated bathroom features a custom vintage claw foot tub for a good soak as well as a separate and spacious stand up shower.”

Amenities

Free parking on premises | Full kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer | Iron

Guest Reviews

“Clean, spacious, charming, great location. Highly recommend!” – Lindsay
“Great Stay! The space looks exactly like the pictures and there are lots of thoughtful details including a very comfortable bed, basic pantry items, and books/magazines. ” – Samantha
“What a beautiful place. It met all of our needs and was extremely clean.” – Brandon
“Stylish, comfortable and cozy apartment will definitely come back!” – Karen Sofía
“Such a cute place, so many cute details” – Brooke

#2 The Aviator House in Downtown Indianapolis

14 Guests | 4 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms

Book Now: $160 per night, airbnb.com

This bright and tastefully decorated space is ideal for a group of friends travelling together to Indiana. It’s a big place with 4 bedrooms that can sleep up to 14 people. Its ample dining room table and the full kitchen will ensure that everyone’s fed during the trip.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Sit on the porch with a cup of coffee and watch the world go by as the fountain provides a soothing background. Built in 1900, this home has been fully renovated, but retains original features such as the oak staircase and decorative fireplace. Enjoy the growing vinyl collection over a home-cooked meal before retiring to a comforting night’s sleep.”

Amenities

Self check-in | Free parking on premises | Full kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer

Guest Reviews

“Great host. Great house and neighborhood.” – Shaun
“Our stay was wonderful! We were all very comfortable and Luke has taken great care to make sure the house is awesome! Definite plus that there was a garage we could park in!” – Audrey
“This was our 2nd stay. It feels like home. Luke is an awesome host!” – Valerie
“This flat is amazing on so many levels! Communication, cleanliness, comfort, friendly, above and beyond, considerate touches, genuine concern are just a few things that instantly upped the warmth of the space. ” – Joel
“We had a wonderful stay. Luke was very helpful and super easy to talk to. The house is amazing and we would definitely look to stay here again. The location could not be better and we always felt safe in and around the home.” – Adam

#3 Duplex in Broad Ripple Near the Village’s Main Strip

3 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $100 per night, airbnb.com

Amazing duplex with WiFi and TV as well as very tastefully decorated with splashes of pop art here and there. It’s the perfect spot for a businesswoman on a solo trip to Indianapolis, although it could also be the ideal fit for a couple or a small family with a single child.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Stroll to the nearby concert venue, restaurants and coffee shops from an eclectically remodelled unit that brings together original and rustic vintage details with modern comforts in a minimalist fashion. Unwind on the private deck or soak in the claw-foot tub at this cozy Duplex. Comfortably hosts two adults. Sleeps 3-4 MAX.”

Amenities

Self check-in | Free parking on premises | Kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer

Guest Reviews

“My husband and I rented this bungalow for my parents for a two month stay around the holidays. It was WONDERFUL. The place is exactly as depicted – cute, warm, tastefully decorated.” – Andrea
“Deborah’s place is incredibly stylish and has everything you need, especially if you need an extended stay. The main strip at Broad Ripple is a hop and a skip away, and the neighborhood is perfect for walking and running. It definitely made my experience in Indy that much more wonderful!” – Phil
“What an amazing place with incredible stylish pieces, in a hip neighborhood on the free redline that can take you almost anywhere you want to go. ” – Momo
“My husband and I stayed at Deborah’s place while visiting family in the area. The decor and style was nicely done. We enjoyed the color palettes and all of the bright light!” – Mindy
“I stayed here for a month and enjoyed every minute. The home was adorable, beautifully decorated, and filled with lots of extra special touches. ” – Mary

#4 Upscale Urban Cabin

5 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $100 per night, airbnb.com

Relax as you enjoy the morning breezes of Indiana in this lovely cabin with two bedrooms and two baths. Perfect for a small family or a group of friends, this spot is one for the record! You definitely cannot miss it!

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Spin classic vinyl at this one-of-a-kind restored retreat built in 1908, then take a stroll to the brewery on the corner for a leisurely evening. Exposed ceiling beams, industrial lighting, ductwork, and cedar windows make for a characterful space.”

Amenities

Self check-in | Free parking on premises | Full kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer

Guest Reviews

“House is quiet and cozy. The host were excellent in responding to my questions in a timely manner. I was not disappointed.” – Lashawna
“Where to begin? I cannot boast enough regarding my recent stay at the Urban Cabin! Matt & Jess were gracious hosts.” – Sam
“Matt & Jess’s place goes above and beyond! Such thoughtful touches and we had the best time with the Sonos speaker as we love music. The place is beautifully decorated and has such a home feel.” – Devyn
“My wife and I spent our honeymoon here. It was an excellent, comfortable experience.” – Spencer
“So comfortable and chic. This will be our go-to place for our many visits to Indy” – Robbie

#5 Modern Duplex in Charming Downtown Neighborhood

6 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $110 per night, airbnb.com

This modern and very elegant three-bedroom house is the place you need to visit with your extended family if you want to impress the in-laws! With a full kitchen and WiFi and a completely spotless interior, this space and its amenities will guarantee a fun time for you and your loved ones.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“This reimagined century-old property features a gas fireplace with wood-panel surround, home office workspace, tiled bathrooms, hardwood flooring, and plenty of space to relax. Cook in a refurbished kitchen of quartz countertops and stainless-steel appliances, and truly find yourself at home away from home. This property includes 2 bedrooms and 3 beds: 1 king, 1 queen, 1 sleeper sofa.”

Amenities

Self check-in | Free parking on premises | Full kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer

Guest Reviews

“Worked out nicely as an alternative to coporate housing. Needed temporary housing while my new construction finished. Would stay again.” – Claudius
“This is a fantastic rental spot that is maintained with the utmost care. Anna was a phenomenal host who was readily available when questions came up and she made check-in and check-out a breeze.” – Matthew
“This place was perfect for us. The kitchen was great and well stocked. The backyard was lovely with great lounge furniture as well as a table.” – Kelley
“Anna’s place is well cared for and was such a great place to retreat to. Love the location and amenities of this place. The bed was super comfortable.” – Casey
“Anna’s bungalow is truly as charming as the pictures. 5/5 would recommend to anyone looking for a place to stay in Downtown Indianapolis! ” – Haley

#6 Urban Elegance Close to Hip Fountain Square

9 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $180 per night, airbnb.com

For those with finer, more elegant tastes, this space is one you need to check out! It comes with four bedrooms and 3.5 baths, and has enough space to accommodate up to 14 guests, making it ideal for a holiday with a bigger family.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Watch the flickering fire as well as the extra-wide TV with surround sound, both set in an exposed-brick corner. A striking peacock portrait showcases the living area, with vibrant accents cleverly echoing its colors in the cushions and furniture.”

Amenities

Self check-in | Free parking on premises | Full kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer

Guest Reviews

“Beautiful home, great location. However, if you are hot natured by any means then the upstairs, at times, is very stuffy and can be unbearable to sleep in.” – Justin
“A truly fantastic stay with excellent communication. I needed a couple things upon check in and Elizabeth responded within 15 minutes. Couldn’t have asked for a better host!” – Erik
“This home was so beautiful and we truly appreciated the price. More great homes should be at reasonably priced amounts. ” – Myia
“We had a really great time in Indianapolis. The place was perfect and nearby everything that we wanted to see including in the zoo. Everything was clean on the inside and the host was amazing. We will definitely go back.” – Mark
“We had a great stay! The house was very clean and is conveniently located to downtown Indy. We’ll be back!” – Lindsey
Let’s Cut The Crap

The Best Airbnbs In 5 Minutes Or Less

Stop wasting time searching for the best Airbnbs. Our “10 Or Less” strategy will show you the unique search method we use to find the top Airbnbs in any city in under 5 minutes—guaranteed. Sign up for instant access.

#7 Ample Townhouse Steps away from Broad Ripple Avenue

10 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $100 per night, airbnb.com

If you’re looking for a fun stay in Broad Ripple Avenue, this three-bedroom apartment is one you should consider. It brings WiFi, a hairdryer, a big and open layout and 3 bedrooms with super comfy beds, making this a place you and your group won’t soon forget.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Rustle up delicious meals in a huge kitchen that comes complete with double sink and marbled counter tops. Afterwards, relax on the massive sectional sofa in front of the 55″ Smart TV. Custom lighting and dark hardwood floors add further style. Awesome place, super close to Broad Ripple!”

Amenities

Self check-in | Free parking on premises | Kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer | Iron

Guest Reviews

“Awesome place, super close to Broad Ripple! The whole place was decorated so cute and made us feel right at home!” – Samantha
“This townhouse is spacious and is a great space for any gathering. The bedrooms are large and there was a lot of storage space. We could walk right onto the Monon or to Broad Ripple easily.” – Lora
“Fantastic town home, centrally located. Tons of amenities in Broad Ripple. Clean, warm, nicely decorated and easy to use. Thanks!” – Adam
“Great place to stay! Very clean and the hosts were very easy to get in touch with and very thoughtful! Will definitely stay here again!” – Kelly
“The place is very clean and spacious. I also love the book collection. The location is walkable to downtown Broad Ripple in a few minutes.” – Tim

#8 Treetop Lodge On the Park

4 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $90 per night, airbnb.com

Open, bright and tastefully decorated, this guest suite in Indiana is an amazing place for a small group of friends or even for a young family. The full kitchen, WiFi and TV, are perfect to cook and entertain and the big terrace underneath the shade of mature oaks is perfect to enjoy that morning brew in peace and quiet!

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“This is a special property; a beautiful, restful 2nd floor lodge retreat with charm & whimsical touches throughout. We searched years for this unique home. It’s immersed in nature, AND in iconic, artsy Broad Ripple.”

Amenities

Free parking on premises | Full kitchen | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer | Iron | Room-darkening shades | Heating

Guest Reviews

“Right from the beginning of reserving their AirBnb for our Indy stay , thru to our departure , Scott tended to any of our questions and needs in a prompt, welcoming and clear way. To highlight a few, all matters regarding our arrival , ie.” – Marion
“Only advice is to read the pamphlet they leave for you in the beginning of your stay because it will probably answer any questions you may have like tv operations or the thermostat. They literally thought of everything!” – Lauren
“Scott was amazing! We had a great weekend in Indianapolis and it was due to Scott and his wife’s great hosting. I highly recommend this to anyone staying in the area.” – Calvin
“Love the Treetop! It’s me preferred place to stay in Indy and I’ll definitely be back, found a great new Thai place right outside the neighborhood too!” – Roy & Beth
“Beautiful, clean, and great host!” – Amanda

#9 Exceptional Mid-Century Home in Downtown

2 Guests | 1 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $60 per night, airbnb.com

This almost monochromatic and elegant home is the place to be with your significant other. With one bedroom and one bathroom as well as amenities such as a pool and a gym, you’ll enjoy every minute of your stay!

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Designed with a blend of modern elements and artistic touches, this stylish apartment offers a peaceful and relaxing stay. Notice how the hardwood floors complement the soft grey decor and take in the views from the private balcony.”

Amenities

Self check-in | Free parking on premises | Pool | Gym | Full kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts

Guest Reviews

“Great location. Walking distance to all that I wanted to see. We parked the car and walked the whole weekend.” – Karen
“This is a super cute apartment with everything you need! It was perfect for my short trip and I felt well taken care of! Great location to with a coffee shop literally on the first floor of the building!” – Mary
“Such a wonderful place! Great Location! Definitely would recommend!” – Jorge
“They were really good at ensuring that I had everything I needed and responded to me well when I had questions. Great place and really nice view of downtown.” – Mindy
“Nicely stylized 1 bedroom apartment for a stay of 2 people. Hosts were accommodating to our needs. Had enough amenities for a quick 2 night stay.” – Jason

#10 Modern Carriage House in Historic Meridian Park

4 Guests | 1 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $140 per night, airbnb.com

Thinking of escaping from everything? You’ve found the best space to do it! Ideal for a couple on their honeymoon or for a single traveller looking for a place to unwind and find inspiration, this space will make you feel right at home and at the same time at a high-class hotel suite!

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Newly built carriage house has modern amenities & was designed with an eye for eclectic decor with west elm and anthropologie. One bedroom, full kitchen, with full glass shower bath, complete with washer & dryer. Experience all Indy has to offer in this centrally located space!”

Amenities

Self check-in | Full kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer | Iron

Guest Reviews

“I came to Indianapolis as a low key bachelorette party weekend for one of my college roommates and was lucky enough to stay at Abby + Bens Airbnb. ” – Autumn
“We had a brief but great stay in Abby’s carriage house. The apartment was tastefully designed yet functional for our toddler and 5 month-old baby. ” – Carrie
“This is a great space! Very comfortable and everything we needed to cook the meal kit we brought with us. Wonderful stay and would definitely return next time we are in Indy.” – Lori
“We had a great stay! It was such a nice place that it had us wanting to stay longer. Great spot for a weekend stay or a long term stay.” – Megan
“Photos don’t do the space justice! It is absolutely stunning and better than we could’ve expected. The space is so cozy and extremely clean.” – Sara

#11 Private and Charming Carriage House Downtown Indy

4 Guests | 1 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $90 per night, airbnb.com

Cozy and homely, this space is perfect for a couple of retirees looking for a nice stay in Indiana. With a kitchen and laptop-friendly space, as well as beautiful spots within the house, this is a great place to create loving memories with you significant other.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Fully modern and brand new private space in our charming carriage house. It has all the amenities you would need to enjoy and explore the beautiful city of Indianapolis. If you are here for work or pleasure, it is perfectly located and easy access to all Indy has to offer so come and explore our great city.”

Amenities

Wifi | Iron | Laptop-friendly workspace | Essentials | TV | Washer | Dryer | Heating | Air conditioning | Hot water | Free parking on premises | Free street parking

Guest Reviews

“Tim & Kevin’s place was perfect for our weekend getaway and provided us with everything we needed for our short stay” – Josalyn
“This home is perfect for picky people. It’s very clean. It’s decorated very tastefully.” – Mettayya
“Stylish and immaculate. Tim & Kevin were very accommodating. This is the nicest Airbnb I’ve stayed in.” – Catherine
“I would highly recommend staying at Tim and Kevin’s place! It was super cute! They added the best finishing touches to make it seem homey!” – Tara
“The Carriage looked and felt even better than expected! The place had exactly what we wanted and more! Also, it was spotlessly clean.” – Karsten

#12 The Farmhouse at Hotel Tango Farms

8 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $60 per night, airbnb.com

Kids will have the time of their lives here! This farmhouse with three bedrooms and 2.5 baths as well as WiFi and TV, is the perfect place for you to teach your kids where our food comes from and how it’s grown. They’re sure to cherish the memories of this Airbnb for life.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“The Farmhouse has been newly renovated and is located right off I65 just a short drive to downtown Indianapolis. The house is situated on a 5-acre farm operated by Hotel Tango Artisan Distillery. The house itself has three bedrooms, two bathrooms, and a large open kitchen and dining area perfect for entertaining. The home was built in the 1850s and has been meticulously remodeled to highlight the rustic charm while giving guests all the modern comforts of home.”

Amenities

Wifi | Iron | Laptop-friendly workspace | Essentials | TV | Washer | Dryer | Heating | Air conditioning | Hot water | Free parking on premises | Kitchen

Guest Reviews

“The farm house is truly beautiful! My favorite parts of the house were the kitchen, master bedroom, and master bathroom. ” – Halley
“This house is conveniently located, close to the highway and 10 minutes from Target. Everything you need in a home away from home, and it was so clean! Loved it.” – Lindy
“Cute place and the kids really liked to wake up and go out to see people working on the farm.” – Matthew
“Ginger’s place was perfect for our girl’s weekend getaway! The home was very cozy, beautiful kitchen. We weren’t bothered by the noise from the highway, it’s more like white noise.” – Andrea
“Excellent location and sparkling clean. We really enjoyed the rustic charm and unique futures of the property. Viewing the beautiful garden was an added bonus.” – Sarah

Straight To Your Inbox

Airbnbs Of The Week

A weekly digest of the most spectacular new Airbnbs around the world - all for $150/night or less. Every Friday.