The 12 Best Airbnbs In Montauk, New York

September 27, 2020
Airbnb
montauk" class="img-responsive wp-image-731235 wp-post-image" alt="" />
At Yore Oyster, we strive to help you make wise financial decisions. We're committed to giving you the most relevant, actionable advice anywhere.

If you’re looking for the best Airbnbs in Montauk, you’ve come to the right place. We combed through thousands of Airbnb listings in Montauk and the surrounding area to find the homes with the best amenities and the most positive reviews at the lowest prices.

#1 Modern Architectural Gem With Panoramic Coastline Views

4 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $850 per night, airbnb.com

Enjoy the contemporary, stylish interior at this wonderful sea-side listing fit for couples or a few friends visiting Montauk together! Views from inside the home cannot be beat, and you are certain to have a memorable experience in this one-of-a-kind, strangely unique stay.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Make a wood fire in a sleek suspended fireplace and enjoy sweeping views of a nature preserve and ocean. Everything in this house, designed by architect David Ling, has a sculptural quality, from unique corrugated wall coverings to rustic place mats.”

Amenities

Free parking on premises | Kitchen | Washer | Dryer | Dishwasher | Wifi | TV | Bathroom essentials | Bedroom comforts | Coffee maker | Hair dryer | Iron

Guest Reviews

“This house has a perfect location and gorgeous views from the second floor. This is what you are paying for here. The beach is just a few steps away, Montauk 15 minutes away, Amagansett town a few minutes.” – Aleks
“This is the best Airbnb I’ve experienced. David was a wonderful host The location is perfect if you want to be at a pristine and secluded beach. The home and it’s amenities were beyond my expectations.” – Gene
“Form over function. This stunning, highly photogenic experimental living situation feels something like a night at the museum. Each piece, be it furniture, wall, or tub, is a concept in prototype form.” – Monica
“There is a two minute walk from David’s house to the beach through this beautiful dune decorated with flowers and pine trees. We really enjoyed the view from the living room, the beach and all the supplies at the house.” – Jessica
“We had a wonderful weekend at David’s home! Truly a unique space and in a perfect location. The views from this home cannot be beat.” – Ariel

#2 Bright And Modern 2000 Square Feet Montauk House

10 Guests | 5 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $1,250 per night, airbnb.com

Let the quiet driveway escort you to this fairytale villa set amid lush green gardens in a serene neighbourhood not too many paces from Lake Montauk’s shores. Let the charming living areas amaze you with simplistic eloquence, and spend time unwinding on the sunny deck featuring a nice Weber grill.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“This is a smartly furnished, relaxing house close to everything that beautiful Montauk has to offer. We are located one mile away from the Montauk Harbor and Bay Beaches and two miles away from Montauk town and the Ocean Beaches.”

Amenities

Wifi | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Air conditioning | Dryer | TV | Essentials | Iron | Heating | Hot water | Children’s books and toys | Free parking on premises

Guest Reviews

“Spacious, comfortable house with a beautiful large yard and outdoor deck in a quiet residential neighborhood! Perfect break from city life. We enjoyed watching deer munch the grass in the back lawn and listening to birds from the deck every morning.” – Kelly
“The space was exactly as advertised. Very clean and well located.” – Christian
“Had an amazing time! The house is exactly as pictured, and Claudia & Jonathan were great and very accommodating hosts. Would definitely stay again!” – Larissa
“Claudia was such an amazing host! She was very responsive and thoughtful. Her house was the perfect weekend getaway and in a great location.” – Saramarie
“Spacious house, great location in Montauk. Owner is helpful and responsive.” – Brock

#3 A Minute’s Walk To Ditch Plains From A Chic Beach House

8 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $1,190 per night, airbnb.com

Another great listing situated right on the Ditch Plains, this is a place for two families of four or a gang of eight buddies that you don’t wanna miss! The largely white interior is complemented by the wooden floors and rustic wood-furnishing which blend together to give that relaxing vacation-home feel.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“1 min walk to Ditch Plains Beach! No parking permit needed . You cannot beat the location of this simple chic beach house. It is yards from beautiful Ditch Plains Beach.”

Amenities

Wifi | Air conditioning | TV | Essentials | Heating | Kitchen | Stove | Oven | Dishwasher | Microwave | Dishes and silverware | Cooking basics

Guest Reviews

“Tabitha was a great host. The location and proximity to both Ditch beach and town were great! Her kitchen housed all the items you’d need to host family dinner. Thanks!” – Brian
“Amazing location, cute little house, well decorated. Tabitha is super reactive and efficient, and very nice!” – Alexandre
“The home is in an awesome location. It is also well appointed and very clean. Tabitha was communicative and relaxed host who made our check in and check out simple and easy.” – Jessica
“The location of this Airbnb is really good. You are minutes away from the beach, that is not as crowded as the main one. You are also minutes away from Montauk, it’s very quick to go to the center to enjoy the restaurants/bars…” – Charly
“Tabitha is a very responsive host. Everything in the house was as-described and was very accommodating for 4 couples. The location was incredible, as we were a very short walk to a great beach. I recommend this house!” – Connor

#4 The Surf Haus – Featuring Sweeping Water Views And Pool

8 Guests | 4 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms

Book Now: $1,980 per night, airbnb.com

Let the simplistic, modern interior excite you at this very open-concept four-bedroom Montauk villa that’s a terrific choice for the elegance-savvy guests. The open areas and relaxing décor will help you bring down the accumulated stress, and you’ll end your holiday with sweet memories of relaxing in this place for years to come.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“This family-friendly, completely renovated beach home comes complete with a brand new gunite pool and gorgeous views. Expansive decking to enjoy grilling fresh seafood and the famous Montauk sunsets from the privacy of your own beach home with sweeping water views of Fort Pond Bay, the ocean, and Long Island Sound.”

Amenities

Wifi | Indoor fireplace | Cable TV | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Air conditioning | Dryer | TV | Essentials | Iron | Heating | Beach essentials

Guest Reviews

“Wonderful Place and Location!” – Miles
“Beautiful spot. Very clean. Responsive owners.” – Parthenia
“Very nice place. Near to everything. The views and sunsets were great.” – John
“Nice and clean! Great location!” – Cindy
“Excellent place which is only a bike ride (provided by house) to town. Clean and spacious. Especially loved the amenities for the babies and the back porch.” – Nick

#5 Ditch Plains Perfection

8 Guests | 4 Bedrooms | 3 Bathrooms

Book Now: $1,120 per night, airbnb.com

Be just blocks away from the spectacular Ditch Plains Beach with surfing, beachcombing, a children’s area, and plenty of sea-fun right close to you. This ultra-modern, newly furbished property is certainly one of the top picks in the whole area and is perfect for a large group of up to eight guests!

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“The most spectacular house in the highly sought after Ditch Plains beach community. Two blocks from that beach yet serenity, privacy and seclusion await in the tucked away location surrounded by a nature preserve and on a lightly travelled street.”

Amenities

Wifi | Indoor fireplace | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Air conditioning | Dryer | TV | Essentials | Iron | Heating | Free parking on premises | Kitchen

Guest Reviews

“Mike was great! The house was a great place to get work done, cook, and hang out. Practically no visible neighbors, and a 5 min walk to the beach.” – Alex
“We had a great weekend at this house – from bikes to beach chairs, from the fireplace to hammock, everything was charming and provide a wonderful experience!” – Gisleine
“This is by far the cleanest and nicest Airbnb I’ve ever stayed at.” – Chris
“Fantastic place with every amenity you can think of to have the perfect Montauk experience. Great location, walk to the beach. surfboards, chairs, bikes, included.” – Dave

#6 Unique Gem In Montauk

6 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $590 per night, airbnb.com

A very private home featuring a large Jacuzzi and a private beach access nearby! The living and dining areas are modern yet have a very rustic feel, and the fully-equipped kitchen ensures your longer-term stays would be nothing short of delightful in this gem of a place for a family of six.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“SUMMER RENTAL Beautifully decorated, uniquely private 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, house 1/2 mile from private beaches (walking distance, 3 minutes by car). Jacuzzi, sits 6 people comfortably, available 05/01 -10/30. BBQ on back deck looks onto beautiful wooded area, and tennis​ court. IN DEMAND: The house accommodates six guests.”

Amenities

Wifi | Indoor fireplace | Cable TV | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Air conditioning | Dryer | TV | Essentials | Iron | Heating | Hot water

Guest Reviews

“Would stay again! Lovely house with a great backyard and location. Anne-Laure was very responsive before & during the booking.” – Paul
“We had an awesome time in this house. It is in a very convenient location, close to the beach and supermarkets (if you have a car). Anne-Laure was very communicative and flexible with our arriving/departing times.” – Marie
“Starkness of the bare trees, reaching upwards ,had its own appeal and gave me the space to just feel settled and embraced for these special few days.” – Myriam
“Amazing house with plenty of room nestled in the woods. The decor and artwork are fabulous and the house is well-maintained. We thoroughly appreciated the private setting and enjoyed time spent on the deck watching deer by the tennis court or hanging in the large jacuzzi.” – Karen
“We had a wonderful stay at Anne-Laure’s place. We were in Montauk for a wedding and the location was great and the house was spacious, clean, and relaxing. I wish we had more time to enjoy the jacuzzi and backyard but hope to be back another time.” – Laura
Let’s Cut The Crap

The Best Airbnbs In 5 Minutes Or Less

Stop wasting time searching for the best Airbnbs. Our “10 Or Less” strategy will show you the unique search method we use to find the top Airbnbs in any city in under 5 minutes—guaranteed. Sign up for instant access.

#7 6-Minute Walk To Ditch Plains Beach

8 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $460 per night, airbnb.com

Boasting a perfect five-star rating, this three-bedroom home for eight guests in Montauk is perfect for two families vacationing together. Featuring bright artwork and thoughtful touches throughout the living space, this place is certain to be the highlight of your trip!

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Great beach house close to Ditch Plains beach with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. 2 queen beds and 2 bunk beds, deck, barbecue, outside shower, huge yard, recreation room. Spend your days at the beach and grill at night. Wifi, tv, and outdoor fire pit.”

Amenities

Wifi | Indoor fireplace | Cable TV | Washer | Air conditioning | Dryer | TV | Essentials | Heating | Free parking on premises | Kitchen | Coffee maker

Guest Reviews

“Lovely house. Walk to beach. Biked to lighthouse. Doesnt get any better” – Maureen
“Great space, close to the water, clean and well decorated!” – Dylan
“We enjoyed our stay a lot. The house is at walking distance from the dich plains beach, with nice trails alongside the shore. This is a nice base also to see the montauk lighthouse, and other trails in the dunes and pinewoods.” – Claire
“Amazing space and amazing host! Would definitely stay again.” – Derek
“Lisa has been a super host during our stay at her Montauk house. She was very attentive and responsive since the day we booked her place. Everything we needed for our Thanksgiving dinner was at the house.” – Nune

#8 Work From A Modern Montauk Cottage

4 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $530 per night, airbnb.com

Modern and private, this lovely house is situated in a tranquil atmosphere, away from the hustle and bustle of metropolitan life. Couples or families will love spending afternoons at the beach, and coming home to a cool outdoor shower before stepping into the meticulously maintained property.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“This contemporary home boasts newly finished hardwood floors, mid-century modern décor and furniture, AC and a working fireplace. With a light- filled open plan layout, this house sleeps five comfortably with two bedrooms and a single sleeper sofa.”

Amenities

Wifi | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Air conditioning | Dryer | TV | Essentials | Iron | Heating | Hot water | Beach essentials | Free parking on premises

Guest Reviews

“Very nice cottage with a great beach vibe. Outstanding location, very close to our favorite beach, Ditch Plains, and many other nice areas. Host Eleanor is great.” – Kevin
“Cute mid century modern house. Good value for Montauk.” – Jesse
“Eleanor’s house is lovely – serene and peaceful but close to everywhere. The outdoor shower is incredible – such a good way to unwind after a day at the beach.” – Becky
“Had a great time at Eleanor’s. The house is secluded and away from the chaos of town, but still close enough that it’s just a short drive away. Loved the outdoor shower after long days at the beach!” – Amber
“Eleanor was always so quick to respond to any questions I had. Her home was in the best location and nearby to the shops and beach. Her place was wonderful and helped make our vacation perfect” – Erin

#9 Montauk Ocean-View 2-Bedroom Cottage

4 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $330 per night, airbnb.com

Enjoy barbecues surrounded by nature at this perfect weekend getaway for a family or group of friends right by the Montauk shoreline. Spend evenings cozying around the warm indoor-fireplace and spend quality time in the nights watching the stars do their magic up in the skies and watching the beacon lights of the passing ships down the horizon.

Amenities

Wifi | Indoor fireplace | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Air conditioning | Dryer | TV | Essentials | Iron | Heating | Hot water | Free parking on premises

Guest Reviews

“The cottage was even nicer and bigger in person. Stunning view of the ocean as the house sat on top of a hill. The pool shared by the community was a nice surprise.” – Alyssa
“Awesome location – right across the street from the beach! Quiet street and pretty landscaping. Pool was nice too!” – Jessica
“The bungalow was clean, stylish, and perfectly located right across from a mostly empty beach and a 5 minute drive from town. Ron was quick to answer any questions we had, and overall we had a great weekend. Would highly recommend.” – Paul
“Perfect location! Close to Main Street and restaurants down by the water. Priceless view of the ocean.” – Dena
“Ron is a wonderful host who was communicative and attentive. The space was clean, the location was amazing, and the experience was perfect.” – Megan

#10 Montauk House Across From Fort Pond

6 Guests | 3 Bedrooms | 2 Bathrooms

Book Now: $860 per night, airbnb.com

Great for a natural-getaway with your pals or colleagues, this lush home consists of three bedrooms, a kitchen with granite countertops, a cozy living room with a fine dining nook, and two well-furnished baths. You’ll get charming views of the Fort Pond right from the deck.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“3-night minimum. Entire main level 3 bedroom house. The owner with dogs lives in the lower level, with a separate entrance. Close to the Surf Lodge!”

Amenities

Wifi | Air conditioning | TV | Essentials | Heating | Hot water | Free parking on premises | Kitchen | Coffee maker | Lockbox | Hair dryer | Hangers

Guest Reviews

“We had a great stay. House is very clean, and location is perfect! Short walk from all the happenings, including the beach.” – Gregory
“Patty’s Place is a wonderful and super spacious house located near everything! Plenty of room for everyone and in a super convenient location- walking distance to shops and restaurants. You even have a nice view of the pond from the porch.” – Helen
“The house was very clean and the location is great.” – Elaine
“Perfect location. Walking distance of everything.” – Romain
“The house was exactly as pictured and had all of the necessities! We also worked remotely during week days when we were here, and the WiFi was EXCELLENT!!Would highly recommend!” – Katie

#11 Pristine Montauk Beach House

4 Guests | 2 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $920 per night, airbnb.com

A super listing for two couples or a family looking to be near a huge golf-course, this Airbnb features two queen beds and is located at a quick 10-minute bicycle ride from the Ditch Plains Beach and to the town centre. Use the complimentary bikes to explore the Montauk area, or take soothing evening strolls in the huge yard.

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Bright and modern beach house conveniently located close to town and ditch plains beach. This completely renovated Leisurama is ideal for couples or a family looking to enjoy a vacation in Montauk. Montauk Down golf course and public tennis courts just down the road. The kitchen is equipped with all modern appliances, including a wine fridge.”

Amenities

Wifi | Indoor fireplace | Washer | Laptop-friendly workspace | Air conditioning | Dryer | TV | Essentials | Iron | Heating | Hot water | Free parking on premises

Guest Reviews

“Federico’s home was awesome! Super clean and a great space! Would highly recommend and we’ll definitely be back!” – Samantha
“So nice to have access to bikes. Yard is lovely with upper and lower deck. Pretty lights over the deck and a fun swing in the yard.” – Jacqui
“Very cozy, sparkling clean, big backyard, great charcoal grill. Only complaint: Wi-Fi could use an upgrade to faster speeds.” – Sasha
“Best place ever. Modern, beautiful, clean, good backyard, and well located. Bycicles from the house can be used, which is a good point.” – Jacobo
“Federico is such a stress free person and everything about this listing is also stress free. He made his brand new bikes available so we could ride to t beach. we saw sunsets and t full moon rise.” – Jupira

#12 Newly Renovated Apartment By The Beach

4 Guests | 1 Bedrooms | 1 Bathrooms

Book Now: $390 per night, airbnb.com

Featuring sleeping quarters for four and a nice open-plan kitchen and lounge area, this homely listing is great for a small family or a group of buddies who like to be out and about in the beachy areas of Montauk. Take a good night’s sleep in the comfy beds before heading off the seaside again in the mornings, sounds like the perfect holiday, right?

Here’s the property description from Airbnb:

“Spacious newly renovated ground level one bedroom one bathroom apartment with outdoor patio and kitchenette, sleeps four, located a short stroll to private ocean beach. Private entrance and outdoor brick patio with BBQ grill, patio chairs and table opens up into this newly renovated air conditioned one bedroom one bathroom (650 sq ft) apartment.”

Amenities

Wifi | Cable TV | Air conditioning | TV | Essentials | Heating | Free parking on premises | Kitchen | Host greets you | Smoke alarm | Carbon monoxide alarm 

Guest Reviews

“Dan always responded quickly and had great tips for local fun and food. Quick stroll to private neighborhood beach. Quiet neighborhood and a place that felt like home after returning from beach.” – Sharon
“Amazing stay in Montauk! Dan was very responsive and the apartment was fully equipped with everything we could need, would definitely recommend to a friend” – Gabrielle
“This is a great spot if you want proximity to the beach and downtown, but still a quiet, secluded place. The grill was a big selling point! Wonderful place.” – Rachel
“My family and i had a great experience. We enjoyed our stay. Everything was clean and any questions I had for Daniel were answered within a short period of time.” – Jackeline
“This place is great – clean, comfortable, stocked with everything you need, and perfectly located! Will return next year!” – Nicole
Straight To Your Inbox

Airbnbs Of The Week

A weekly digest of the most spectacular new Airbnbs around the world - all for $150/night or less. Every Friday.